Tag Archives: durbin amendment

Durbin Amendment Ready To Go [2023 Update]

Leave a reply

The Official Merchant Services Blog continues to keep its finger on the pulse of the Durbin Amendment media buzz. The legislation that marks regulation that caps debit card swipe fees begins to take effect on October 1, 2011. And there’s still a lot of scrambling from various media sources to try and predict how banks, merchants and consumers will be impacted by the cap on the billion dollar payment processing industry.

Host Merchant Services has been ahead of the curve in both its analysis of the legislation and its reaction to the legislation.

Today, The Official Merchant Services Blog takes a look at two different articles discussing the Durbin Amendment and the changes it brings.

Banks Plan to Recoup Durbin Losses With Other Fees

The first article comes from mainstreet.com. It’s a pretty standard discussion of the most predicted reaction: Banks will react to the losses that the Durbin Amendment cap places on their swipe fee revenue from previous years by creating new service fees for debit card use. So instead of charging per swipe, the banks move the charge directly to the cardholder as a service fee for having debit card services available to them.

The article cites a robust number of debit card users in the U.S.:

“Americans sure love their debit cards. Between Visa  and MasterCard there are more than 520 million debit cards in use nationwide today. “

That frames the basis of why banks are working to come up with a reaction to the Durbin Amendment. With that many debit card users in the country, there are billions of dollars in profit being cut into with the swipe cap. As the article explains, a quarterly survey of debit card use by financial consumers produced by Manhattan-based Auriemma Consulting Group finds: “banks remain stung by changes in debit card fees (called interchange fees) that reduced the amount of fees banks could charge customers for debit card transactions. The changes, which were triggered by the Durbin Amendment in the Dodd-Frank financial reform bill, basically cut debit card transaction fees in half, the ACG reports.”

The article goes on to explain how many banks are wary over the consumer backlash that could result from charging monthly fees for debit card use and scaling back or restricting reward points programs. The article quotes  Ed Lawrence, director of the debit marketing roundtable at the ACG as saying: “The first-movers to institute debit/checking fees in a given market will experience the most scrutiny and possible attrition, along with negative press; as others follow, customers will have fewer places to move to.”

The conclusion drawn from the article is that Durbin puts the banks in a position where they have to react with changes in how they offer debit card services. And the most likely choices are consumer fees for debit card usage and/or reward points programs being restricted or removed. The banks know these choices will be unpopular with consumers but there’s likely to be a domino effect where once a few banks do it, many more will follow suit, leaving consumers with less and less alternatives.

Some Tips On Dealing With Durbin

The second article comes from USA Today’s Money section. Sandra Block offers some insight into Durbin that mirrors much of the insight every other article about Durbin that The Official Merchant Services Blog has reviewed. But Block offers consumers advice on how to deal with the changes that Durbin is going to bring to their wallets: “The good news: There are numerous ways to avoid these fees. Some tips …”

Block offers four basic tips for consumers to do in response to their bank’s reaction to the Durbin Amendment.

  • Tip 1: Forget about interest checking accounts. Block notes that the increased cost of maintaining this type of account ($5,587 for the interest account vs. $585 for the non-interest account) isn’t worth the 0.08% interest the account offers.
  • Tip 2: Set up direct deposit. Block notes that many banks offer to waive checking account fees for customers who set up direct deposit.
  • Tip 3: Consider switching to a small bank or credit union. Block notes that banks and credit unions with assets lower than $10 million are exempt from the Durbin Amendment changes.
  • Tip 4: Watch out for Debit Card fees. Block’s final tip is for consumers to pay close attention to their debit card fees. Many banks may not change immediately and be slower to react to Durbin so consumers should be aware of the details of their statements going forward.

The Official Merchant Services Blog keeps finding the same theme that the media is bringing up about the Durbin Amendment. Banks do not want to lose the billions of dollars that their transaction fees were bringing them prior to the swipe fee cap. So they are going to find ways to move things around to keep the revenues coming in. And many of the proposed changes are ideas that will end up being shouldered by the consumers. The demographic that this finance reform legislation was initially supposed to assist.

E-Commerce uses Mobile Payments and Near Field Communications as new Merchant Services Solutions

Payment Processing Changes and How They Effect Small Businesses

Leave a reply

It used to be one of the big decisions a small business had to make was whether or not to accept credit cards. But with E-commerce booming and consumers continually reaching for plastic instead of paper for their transactions, that decision has pretty much been made for small businesses. They have to accept some form of card payment as fewer people carry cash. However, the technology for payment processing is advancing at a high rate right now. And many studies predict mobile payments are on the verge of transforming the way people pay for things even more than before. The future of payment processing is ripe for change.

The Current Payment Processing Landscape At A Glance

Merchant Services, by its very nature, is an industry that for the most part seeks to work unnoticed by the consumer. The companies performing this service, which can be explained here in this Host Merchant Services infographic, tend to make their money off of percentages of a penny. Transaction by transaction those percentages grow into pennies, and as volume increases even further those pennies increase into dollars.

A lot of small business owners have horror stories about their payment processors because a really common practice that companies in the industry started to do to each other to compete better, was to boost the expenses from those transactions, and those percentages of pennies, with hidden fees and contractual obligations.

It got so bad that federal legislation, in the form of the Durbin Amendment, was passed as a way to combat debit card swipe fees. Host Merchant Services is already tracking the effects of those changes in a series right here on the Official Merchant Services Blog.

Changing the Game

But that’s not the only way the game is changing. Some companies, like Host Merchant Services, see the opportunity being created by the old standard. So HMS shines light on hidden fees, cuts away the fat from these agreements and HMS even goes so far as to not hold its merchants to contracts or termination fees.  Many of the features you find at Host Merchant Services are designed specifically to appeal to small business owners. A service oriented Merchant Services solution that lets the merchant know exactly what they are paying on their statement.

Technology Adds its Own Wrinkle

Beyond just what Host Merchant Services is doing to change the model for Merchant Services Providers, the industry is being shaped by advances in technology, specifically the potential for profits from mobile payments. Small Business Owners are starting to find the convenience of being able to process a payment anywhere can give them more flexibility to reach their customers. And so the companies developing the technology for these mobile payments are racing to reach the market with their ideas and advances.

Square Up  –  In 2009 the Co-Founder of Twitter, Jack Dorsey, introduced a breakthrough device that allows both individuals and businesses to swipe and process credit cards directly on their iPhone or Android phone. While Square was not the first company to do this, what set them apart was their fee structure and their lack of a contract. Square has no contract, does not have any monthly fees and only charges when a card is swiped or keyed in. They currently charge 2.75% of the transaction for each swiped card. This is their big selling point because Square lets small businesses that did not have the resources prior to begin accepting credit cards. This is appealing to small businesses with low or inconsistent volume that would normally be burdened by the heavy costs associated with setting up a merchant account.

Google Wallet  – On the other side of the payment world there is Google, who partnered with Citibank to create a new product called Google Wallet. This new mobile payment technology allows consumers to attach a credit card number to an embedded near-field communications (NFC) chip in their Android phone. This in turn gives that person the ability to make payments by swiping their mobile phone next to a chip reader.

NFC technology has been around for about a decade, and is still being tested in target market areas. Google Wallet will be tested first in New York City and Google hopes to roll it out for the rest of the country in 2012. Host Merchant Services noted this previously in an article.

HMSPay  – Host Merchant Services offers its own mobile payment solution, HMSPay. This is similar to Square in that it’s a device that attaches to an iPhone. And its big selling point is that it adheres to HMS’ standards of service and savings. Merchants who use it are able to get ultra-competitive rates that let small businesses take credit cards without being overwhelmed by hidden fees and other excesses found in the Merchant Services industry.

 

 

What Durbin Will Change

Roundup of What Durbin Will Change

Leave a reply

The changes to interchange fees and debit card transactions brought on by the Durbin Amendment are just days away. The Official Merchant Services Blog is going to give its readers a quick hit of some of the chatter that is heating up the internet as we close in on the day the changes take effect. As with the previous articles, we’ll be using Host Merchant Services’ own Durbin Analysis as the foundation for comparison. We’ll be touching on 3 separate articles today so the comparison will be brief and focus on the highlights.

Citigroup Focuses on Credit Cards

The first article we find comes from The Wall Street Journal. This article points out how Citigroup is reacting to the changes that its competitors Wells Fargo and SunTrust are making because of the Durbin Amendment. Both of which were reported in our last Countdown To Durbin Blog, but can be summed up as both of those banks are going to implement a fee for debit card use that its customers have to pay each month.

Citigroup, according to the Wall Street Journal, is pushing an aggressive credit card campaign to its customers. Citi mailed an estimated 346 million credit card offers to North American customers in the third quarter of this year, the Wall Street Journal reported in the article.  The article suggests this move is at least partially motivated by a void that will be created by the Durbin Amendment:

“One potential void was created last year by an addition to the Dodd-Frank Act, which overhauled financial regulation. Known as the Durbin Amendment, the new rules, which go into effect in October, will limit the fees that banks collect from merchants each time a debit card is swiped, making cards far less profitable for the issuers.

As a result, some issuers are making debit cards less attractive by charging monthly fees and eliminating rewards. Citi is hoping to capitalize on this change by convincing dissatisfied debit customers to use its credit cards instead.”

This builds off of what our previous article found, that Durbin focuses on debit card transactions so one viable reaction to the Durbin changes is to switch focus to Credit Card Processing.

Consumer Reaction To “Too Many Fees”

The next article we cite comes from an NBC news affiliate in Indianapolis, IN, wthr.com. This article contains some evocative reaction from consumers regarding debit card fees. It cites what Regions Bank is doing in reaction to the changes from the Durbin Amendment:

“Regions issued a statement saying regulations have changed and, as a result, banks are adjusting how they cover the costs of providing debit cards. For some customers, that will mean a monthly fee for a debit card beginning in October. While Regions and other banks say the change is necessary, it isn’t popular.”

Which we have cited before as being a very popular reaction from banks regarding the federal regulations. This article quotes debit card using consumer reaction:

“I think it’s my money and I shouldn’t have to pay to use it,” said Andrea Moxley.

“Enough is enough. Too many fees,” said another woman.

This underscores the reaction that many of these articles are finding. Consumers, the group the legislation was supposed to help with its reforms, are not pleased with the shifted burdens that end up not helping them in the end.

Merchants Can Save

The final article we cite comes from Jennifer D’Angelo. It’s a blog of hers that goes into detail about how Merchants can take advantage of the Durbin Amendment changes to save money. D’Angelo suggests Merchants can save up to $1,200 per year because of the Durbin Amendment. She states:

“Under a new law called the Durbin Amendment that takes effect Oct. 1, any merchant that takes debit cards — from retail stores, restaurants, gas stations, and small businesses like chiropractor’s offices — could be eligible for up to $1,200 a year in savings on debit card processing.

In order to be eligible for savings, you need to ask your payment processor if they are passing along the benefits under the Durbin Amendment.”

It’s a very short piece that essentially suggests contacting your payment processor for more information about savings. But it does include the statistics about the cap the Durbin Amendment brings to debit card swipe fees (the previously reported 24 cents on the average purchase) as well as the cost of swipe fees in the past year (the also previously reported 44 cents on the average purchase). Which underscores how much of a difference the Durbin Amendment is forcing on the individual transactions.

These articles give three different perspectives on the Durbin Amendment: Bank, Consumer and Merchant. And gets right to the heart of the issue: Where will the savings that the legislation was designed to create actually end up going? Banks are making moves to protect the huge profit margins the fees provided them prior to the regulation. Merchants are capable of getting some savings, but it hinges on what their payment processors can do. And consumers may end up having to pay the same amount as fees get shifted to other, unregulated areas in the infrastructure of bank services.

durbin preparations continue

Durbin Preparations Continue [2023 Update]

Leave a reply

The Official Merchant Services Blog is staying on top of the Durbin Amendment. Today’s article that we analyze comes from the New York Daily News.
The first thing that stands out about this article compared to many of the others on the impending Durbin date of October 1, is the casual, but easy to relate to lead of the story. The New York daily news appeals to its readers with some examples of other common cost increases that everyone who might pick up this story can relate to: An increase in toll costs and an increase in Netflix subscription costs. With those two things firmly entrenched in the reader’s mind, the article then shifts into discussion about the Durbin Amendment. And like Host Merchant Services said back when it analyzed the legislation, the New York Daily news makes the point that consumers are going to feel the heat from the cap on swipe fees.

Key Summation of the Durbin Amendment

key summation of the Durbin Amendment

The key summation of the Durbin Amendment from this article is short and to the point:

“The new legislation, called the Durbin Amendment, roughly cut the amount banks can charge retailers who swipe your debit card – known as an interchange fee – in half.

That’s great for retailers, who were paying an average of 44 cents per transaction, but bad for banks. In some ways, at least, it’s bad for customers, too.”

The Daily News article points out two banks are shifting the burden directly to its customers: Wells Fargo, which is testing a $3 monthly fee for debit card users in 5 states, and SunTrust which has already announced it is launching a new account type, Everyday Checking, that charges $5 a month for debit card use. These examples show that the banks are simply making a lateral move with the fees, so that they are no longer found under the scope of Durbin, but are still being extracted from consumers.

These examples follow suit with the current media landscape that is finding more and more banks ready to unveil new programs and changes to their services all related to the Durbin Amendment. But the article does go on to explain that some of these changes are still in the testing phase, and a detail oriented customer may be able to find ways to avoid these debit fees by taking advantage of other services and perks their bank provides.

The next big thing the article mentions is banks scaling back on debit card rewards programs. Host Merchant Services found this to be a likely reaction to Durbin Amendment changes as well when it analyzed the legislation.

The article concludes, however, with some information that recent articles about the legislation have been less inclined to delve into: Credit cards. The legislation primarily attacks debit card swipe fees, and this opens up a lot of potential for the big credit card companies to vie for consumers to switch from debit to credit. And the article makes a final point about how smaller banks can end up exempt from the changes. So it leaves the reader with a lot of different options on how to deal with any challenges they may face with their purchasing choices on October 1.

The Durbin Amendment is big news right now for merchant services providers

The Countdown Begins

Leave a reply

Host Merchant Services has been ahead of the curve on the Durbin Amendment, and its impact on the merchant services industry. The amendment takes effect on October 1, 2011. Between now and then The Official Merchant Services Blog is going to link to and analyze a new article from an outside source that discusses the changes brought on by the Durbin Amendment as well as how those changes affect Merchant Services Providers and their customers.

The first article we look at was published by The Green Bay Press Gazette. You’ll find that quite a few of the articles delving into these changes are predicting that consumers will not benefit from the legislation, despite the fact that consumers were specifically cited as the catalyst for this reform. And that’s also what Host Merchant Services predicted with its Durbin Amendment Analysis.

As the Gazette article states:

“Consumers, who are supposed to be protected by the new cap, might not be happy either if banks impose other fees to make up for the lost income.”

The Gazette provides some compelling statistics as the reason for the consumer consternation over the upcoming changes. Specifically noting that initially the Durbin Amendment was supposed to cap swipe fees Continue reading →