Offering subscriptions nowadays is the strategic way businesses can hold onto paying customers. Whether it is a streaming platform like Prime Video or Netflix, a music streaming platform like Spotify, or a meal delivery platform like SnackNation – these subscription services offer value and convenience to the customers. 

However, they also bring challenges, especially when we look at the customer retention schemes they follow; they make it hard for customers to exit the subscription plans. Following the rise of businesses using this practice to retain customers, almost 70 customers complained to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) that subscription cancellation processes are intentionally convoluted, often using “dark patterns” that obscure or complicate the cancellation option. In response, FTC has introduced a final rule named “Click-to-Cancel” to avoid negative option marketing. This rule will change how subscriptions work today across industries.

What Is the Background and Rationale of “Click-to-Cancel”

Over the past decade, subscription-based models have proliferated across industries – from streaming media and software services to subscription boxes and mobile apps. While signing up for these services is often a streamlined, user-friendly process, canceling a subscription frequently requires navigating multiple screens, completing lengthy questionnaires, or contacting customer service.

In light of a surge in customer grievances, reported by the FTC to have risen from 42 per day in 2021 to 70 in 2024, subscription-based businesses are urgently compelled to reevaluate their cancellation procedures.

The Federal Register recently included the publication of the Click-to-Cancel rule, which is crucial for defining the timelines for implementation, with most stipulations becoming active 180 days post-publication.

With 80% of SaaS companies adopting subscription models, managing cancellations effectively is paramount. This approach reflects a company’s dedication to customer satisfaction and influences customer retention and loyalty. Companies that streamline the cancellation process will likely benefit from maintaining customer loyalty.

Such practices have led to consumer frustration and unexpected recurring charges. In response to mounting evidence of these issues and related legal challenges, the FTC has ensured that canceling a subscription is as straightforward as signing up.

Key Provisions of the “Click-to-Cancel” Rule

The rule defines several practices as unfair and deceptive under Section 5 of the FTC Act:

• Misrepresentations: Sellers are prohibited from misrepresenting any material fact related to the negative option feature, including terms, costs, product efficacy, or any other information likely to influence consumer decisions.
• Disclosures: Before obtaining a consumer’s billing information, sellers must clearly and conspicuously disclose all material terms of the hostile option offer. This includes details about subscription payments, the deadline before you can stop the charges, billing dates, cancellation methods, and related costs.
• Affirmative Consent: Businesses must obtain the consumer’s unambiguous confirmed consent on the negative option feature before billing and charging their accounts. This consent must be separate from other parts of the transaction, ensuring consumers fully know what they agree to.
• Simple Cancellation Mechanism (“Click-to-Cancel”): Sellers should provide a straightforward and accessible method for consumers to cancel the negative option feature. The cancellation process should be as easy as the method used to sign up and must be available through the same medium. For instance, if a consumer subscribed online, they should be able to cancel online without interacting with a live or virtual representative.

The rule also establishes several mandatory requirements for businesses offering subscription services:

• Prominent Cancellation Option: Companies must display a visible cancellation button on their websites and mobile applications. This button must be as accessible as the option to subscribe, ensuring that consumers are not forced to search for the cancellation link.
• One-Click Cancellation Process: As mentioned, the rule mandates that the cancellation process should involve no more steps than the subscription process. Consumers must be able to cancel their subscriptions with a single click without navigating through multiple menus or forms.
• Equal Ease in Subscription and Cancellation: Businesses must ensure that the cancellation process is not deliberately more complicated than the subscription process. This measure is intended to eliminate misleading interfaces that intentionally obstruct consumers from terminating unwanted services.
• Immediate or Clearly Defined Cancellation Effectiveness: Once a cancellation is initiated, it must take effect immediately or within a clearly stated, short timeframe. Consumers must receive a confirmation of cancellation so they have clear evidence that the service will no longer charge them.
• Transparent Terms and Conditions: Companies must provide clear disclosure regarding any conditions associated with cancellation, such as the possibility of a cancellation fee, refund policies, or any outstanding obligations. This ensures that consumers are fully informed before they subscribe and when they decide to cancel.

The revised Rule broadens its scope beyond online damaging option purchases to include those made through any medium, such as over the phone, in person, or via print. It clarifies that a negative option feature involves a contractual element where a consumer’s lack of response or failure to decline a service or product or to cancel an agreement is taken by the seller as approval or ongoing consent to the proposal.

This definition includes schemes such as automatic renewals, continuity subscriptions, transitions from free to paid services, and prenotification of harmful option plans, covering all mediums through which they may be presented to consumers.

How Does This New Rule Benefit the Consumer? How Does It Impact the Market?

For consumers, the “Click-to-Cancel” rule offers significant advantages:

• Enhanced Control: Consumers gain the ability to manage subscriptions on their terms without having to navigate confusing cancellation processes.
• Prevention of Unwanted Charges: By streamlining the cancellation process, the rule helps prevent consumers from inadvertently being locked into recurring billing cycles.
• Increased Transparency: With clearly displayed cancellation options and immediate confirmation of cancellation, consumers can have greater confidence in managing their subscriptions.
• Prevention of “Dark Patterns”: The rule addresses manipulative design tactics, known as “dark patterns,” that complicate the cancellation process. Businesses are now required to provide a cancellation mechanism as simple as the method used for enrollment, reducing deceptive practices that previously made cancellations challenging.
• Increased Business Accountability: By enforcing clear disclosure of material terms and obtaining explicit consumer consent before charging, the rule holds businesses accountable for transparent practices. This encourages a marketplace where consumer rights are upheld and enterprises operate more transparently.

The rule necessitates a review and potential overhaul of existing digital interfaces and business customer service protocols. Companies that previously relied on complex cancellation procedures to retain customers must align their practices with the FTC’s requirements. Although this may involve short-term adjustments and potential reengineering of digital platforms, compliance is expected to foster greater consumer trust and long-term customer loyalty.

Enforcement and Legal Considerations

The FTC enforces the “Click-to-Cancel” rule under its mandate to protect consumers against unfair and deceptive practices. Non-compliance can result in significant penalties, including fines and legal action. The rule builds on existing consumer protection laws by addressing a specific area – subscription cancellations – that has been identified as problematic in numerous enforcement actions and investigations.

Here’s a look at the consequences of failing to adhere to regulations:

• Monetary Sanctions: Companies that breach this regulation could incur monetary sanctions of up to $51,744 for each infraction. A single transaction could comprise multiple infractions, which might escalate the total fines considerably.
• Consumer Compensation: The FTC can enforce consumer compensation measures, including refunds and damages payments to those adversely affected by a company’s non-compliance.
• Corrective Measures: Besides monetary fines, the FTC may enforce corrective measures, requiring companies to amend their operational procedures to align with regulatory standards. This might include adopting transparent cancellation procedures and explicit communication of subscription details.

Considering the severe implications and the FTC’s dedication to upholding the “Click-to-Cancel” rule, it is crucial for companies providing subscription services to evaluate and potentially modify their operational policies to ensure they are in full compliance.

Legal experts have noted that the rule is rooted in established consumer protection principles and is designed to reduce information imbalance between businesses and consumers. While some companies may challenge the implementation details in court, early indications suggest that the rule will likely withstand judicial scrutiny due to its clear basis in preventing deceptive business practices.

Conclusion

The FTC’s “Click-to-Cancel” rule is a significant step toward protecting consumers by making it easier to end unwanted subscriptions. The rule ensures that the same simple method used to sign up is available for cancellation, eliminates misleading practices, and requires clear disclosure of all material terms before a customer is charged.

These changes are designed to enhance transparency, prevent deceptive retention tactics, and hold companies accountable for the fair treatment of their subscribers. As the new rule takes effect, businesses must update their procedures, which is expected to lead to a more equitable and straightforward marketplace for consumers.

Frequently Asked Questions